Englands Joe Root struck a magnificent 124 on day one of the first Test against India - but was he cut off in his prime? The 25-year-old fell when he drove his 180th ball back to seamer Umesh Yadav, who grabbed it a thigh height with both hands before tossing the ball in the air in such a manner to raise doubt as to whether the seamer had control of the ball.A smiling Yadav then palmed the ball up in the air, suggesting he had no doubt of the validity of the catch, and the soft signal from the umpires was out. Root briefly looked back but barely hesitated as he left the crease and former England captain Mike Atherton thought the dismissal was right to stand. A pick of the action from the first day of the first Test in Rajkot It looked to me like Yadav caught it but in the process of throwing the ball up he lost control of the ball but he did have it in his hands; thats why the on-field umpires gave it out initially and why Rob Tucker has decided to stay with that call, he said.Fellow Sky Sports pundit Nasser Hussain was less certain.In real-time, thats what we live in, the law is you have to be in control of the ball and your body. Thats the law to claim a catch. Was he in control, real-time, of that ball to claim a catch? The story of Day One Catch up with the key moments from the first day of the first Test between England and India If he was in control of it, why did he try to catch it again?After stumps, Root said: Its out, isnt it? Theres no point arguing it. I set off walking off anyway so, lets leave it at yet. Almost 1,500 followers of @SkyCricket had their say on Twitter - 66 per cent of whom said that, in their opinion, the umpires had reached the wrong decision.Click on the video at the top of the story and decide for yourself whether the officials got the decision right or not.Live coverage of the first Test between India and England continues on Sky Sports 2 and across selected mobile devices. Watch the complete Test for £10.99 with no contract, with a Week Pass from NOW TV. Also See: Commentary Scorecard D1 highlights Broad on 100 caps NMD_R1 Shoes Canada . The Islanders dealt Thomas Vanek to the Montreal Canadiens after less than a year on Long Island. Meanwhile, the Oilers dealt long-time sniper Ales hemsky to the Ottawa Senators on Wednesday for a fifth-round pick in 2014 and a third-rounder in 2015. NMD R2 Canada . Pirlo limped out of Sundays 1-0 win over Udinese after just 13 minutes. Juventus says Pirlo underwent tests on Monday which revealed he has "a second-degree lesion to the collateral medial ligament in his right knee. http://www.nmdshoescanada.com/ultra-boost-cheap-canada.html .500 on the season. The Jets are now 0-5-1 in the second game of back-to-backs. The game started the same way the Vancouver game started the night before, with the Jets taking the first two penalties of the game and killing off the first, but the Oilers getting on the board first, scoring on the second man-advantage. Ultra Boost 19 Sale Canada . Brandon Morrow allowed five runs on six hits over three innings. He struck out two, walked one and hit a batter. Edwin Encarnacion had a two-out, bases loaded two-RBI double in the third inning. NMD 2020 Cananda . LOUIS -- St. The Miami Heat will play?at Oklahoma City on Monday night facing Russell Westbrook and the Thunder. But theyll still feel at home as the team will break out its first alternate uniform of the season. It will?pay homage to fallen soldiers from across?South Florida.The jerseys will include patches with names of those?who died serving?their country.Each Heat player and coach will be paired with a different South Florida Gold Star service member and their family to pay homage to tthe life of their fallen loved one, according to the Heat, via the Sun Sentinel.ddddddddddddIncluding Monday, the team is expected to wear the jerseys in their next five games: Nov. 10 at home against the Chicago Bulls, Nov. 12 against the visiting Utah Jazz, Nov. 14?at San Antonio and Nov. 15 back at home against the Atlanta Hawks.-- Josiah Turner ' ' '